• News
  • Money

Labor case goes in front of Supreme Court

Labor case goes in front of Supreme Court

The group was protesting a Supreme Court case that could potentially dismantle union protections.

Pro-union speakers said they are not confident of a victory at the Supreme Court, which is ruled by a conservative majority of five justices.

"What it effectively does is allow for people to freeload off the system", she said.

Every month, part of my paycheck goes to the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees.

"It's been awful public policy".

At issue is the Illinois Public Labor Relations Act, which gave most government workers the legal right to engage in collective bargaining in 1984. More generally, though, the conservative Gorsuch's originalist views suggest he may be skeptical of the union's side of the case.

"This is changing law that has been established law for 41 years", Hebert said.

Because, as Justice Sonia Sotomayor suggested, the people behind Janus v. AFSCME "are basically arguing, do away with unions".

Janus doesn't want to be forced to pay for something he doesn't agree with.

"The fundamental issue is my right to choice", Janus said Monday. Janus was required to pay a "fair share" or "agency" fee to the labor union, which is a private organization, which the Abood case and government policy says has the exclusive ability to represent him in his labor negotiations.

The Freedom Foundation counsel echoed the concerns of President Franklin Delano Roosevelt, who warned against the very idea of public sector unions.

Since 1977, the Supreme Court has held that public employees who don't want to join a union can't be charged union dues - but state and local governments may require them to contribute a lesser fee toward contract-related costs.

Because President Donald Trump appointed Gorsuch, union members are anxious that the court will rule against them. However, Justice Scalia's death between the date of the oral argument and the decision meant that the Court ended up with a 4-4 tie. "I don't care what (the Supreme Court justices) say, you're going to be represented".

Gorsuch, President Donald Trump's appointee to fill Scalia's seat, has been seen as providing the fifth vote for the conservatives, but he was uncharacteristically quiet during Monday's argument.

Unions say they are entitled to the fees because they're negotiating on behalf of all public workers - even those who don't choose to join, but who nonetheless benefit from the pay and benefits the unions win. There is a direct correlation, she said, between her union's ability to negotiate and what happens in OH classrooms.

"When you compel somebody to speak, don't you infringe that person's dignity?" he asked.

Cropper pointed to a report from the national publication Education Week to prove her point. The experience in other states which have opted for right-to-work status has been dramatic.

"5-4 in favor of the plaintiff and against the union", Napolitano said.

Liberal Justice Elana Kagan stressed how disruptive a ruling against the unions would be, leading to thousands of labor contracts being renegotiated and striking down laws in more than 20 states.

Neal noted the decision in the Janus case is "more of a state and local issue than a federal issue", because the fees at issue here aren't paid by unionized feds.

Leave Your Comment

Leave Your Comment

Latest News

Breaking News


Canara Bank brings to light Rs 515 cr fraud

The accused company availed bank funds on the basis of false and fabricated stock/receivables/debtors statements. Panja and Roy were once known to be influential in West Bengal's political circles.

The Gender Of Khloe Kardashian's Baby Has Leaked

Regardless of what you may think of Kim Kardashian and Kanye West, you have to agree that they make some good looking babies. Kim seemed pretty confident that she was going to win on Saturday but the KarJenners were just as determined.

Samsung Galaxy S9+ Camera: Just How Good It Actually Is

Samsung has finally fixed the positioning of the fingerprint scanner, which is now positioned directly below the camera module. The S9 can flip between two apertures: opening up for 28 per cent more light in the dark and closing back up for bright shots.

Nokia 1 Included In The First List of Android Go Handsets

Powered by a quad-core MediaTek 1.28GHz processor, the handset comes with a choice of 1GB and 2GB RAM and 16GB internal storage. So all the music lovers can rejoice their time by listening to various radio stations through this entry-level device.

Apple moves iCloud encryption keys for Chinese users to China

Despite Cook's sunny outlook, USA lawmakers have criticized Apple for bending to Chinese demands. Human rights activists are concerned because it could lead to arrests of democracy advocates.

Rams gave a fourth and a 2019 second for Marcus Peters

He'll certainly get all the attention he could want without looking for it with antics. At only 25 years old, this seems like a steal for the Rams in acquiring Peters .

Canadian athlete charged with stealing car: S.Korean police

All three have been restricted from leaving South Korea, though their case will be expedited through the legal process. Police found Duncan and his wife Maja Duncan in the back seat of a hummer allegedly stolen near the Athlete's Village.

Winter Olympics 2018: Ledecka makes history in Pyeongchang

The 22-year-old sporting polymath - she is also a fine windsurfer and has Tokyo 2020 on her mind - emphatically proved otherwise. Trapp, 29, started out in all five snowboarding disciplines but was encouraged by his coaches to choose freestyle or racing.

Democrats Decline To Endorse Feinstein: Morse Gets House Endorsement

That means neither candidate will get the party's seal of approval or extra campaign cash leading into the June primary. Feinstein is a popular figure among Democratic voters and has the money to run a successful election campaign.

Omarosa: Leaving White House like being 'freed off a plantation'

The first (Can we pray, the last?) celebrity edition of " Big Brother " came to an end Sunday night and a victor was crowned. We started the night with only five celebrities left in stock, and in pretty short order we sold out of three of them.